Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: Why was the Boomtown Rats artwork so poor?


Dave

Status: Offline
Posts: 408
Date:
Why was the Boomtown Rats artwork so poor?
Permalink  
 


Looking through the Rats album and single covers and on the whole, there were mostly pretty bad.

There are some good single covers for Looking After Number 1, Mondays and Someone's Looking, also Tonic and V Deep have good album covers, but elsewhere they generally look crap.

Surfacing could well be one of the worst covers ever and the pastel colours of Mondo Bondo don't really grab the attention.  Even the covers for the compilations were all pretty dull.

The reason this struck me was seeing the Clash Singles CD.  It looked good, and though it is probably the tenth time they have reissued their hits, I was pretty impressed by the packaging.

Even back in the late seventies, the Stranglers, Blondie and the Sex Pistols among others all seemed to have an identifiable style in their covers

http://www.cyberspace7.btinternet.co.uk/pagee.htm


__________________
 What is this guy talking about? 


The biggest Geldof fan in the world, bar none!

Status: Offline
Posts: 6293
Date:
Permalink  
 

I'm sure we all know that the answer is that they (well Bob) was too tight to pay for anything more professional.smile

__________________
Love Julesxxx
Bob's personal Hippy Angel - well in my dreams ;-)
http://www.facebook.com/home.php#/profile.php?id=709427348&ref=profile
http://www.facebook.com/BobGeldofFans


Dave

Status: Offline
Posts: 408
Date:
Permalink  
 

Jules wrote:

I'm sure we all know that the answer is that they (well Bob) was too tight to pay for anything more professional.smile



This must have taken an age to come up with....

519JRE3VGTL._AA240_.jpg 

Suppose it could have been worse, this cost £400,000 ....

_43005619_london_new_pink_203.gif

Whereas, let's be honest this does rock.....
51T2BbCSjwL._AA240_.jpg

If only that had said THE BOOMTOWN RATS - THE SINGLES with that RATS arband logo.....


__________________
 What is this guy talking about? 


The BoomTown Kid

Status: Offline
Posts: 154
Date:
Permalink  
 

Well I use the background of 'tonic for' ie. the white with just the blue dripping down as my computer desktop (the boys aren't on it). So many people comment on it and know what it is, its held an impact some thirty years later for people who wouldn't be particularly big fans. This graphic 'design' is pretty up there in my opinion. Who would turn their nose up on a design which has survived 30 years.
The first album cover taken in garys attic, I think, has a lot of impact. It said a statement, of its time, about the band.
Garys dad Rex was a big photographer in Ireland at the time (he still is i think). Google him. I'm sure a lot rubbed off on Gary, plus he would have had a lot of professional equipment at his disposal.
Also one or two of the others went to art college studying the graphic design or draughtsman thing, if i'm not mistaken?
I would guess the idea was 'experiment'. They definitely got it right on the first two albums.
By the way, the Clash didn't work for me when they used the M*A*S*H font on that (singles) album cover!
Not that I have anything against MASH, but aligning yourself to Hawkeye, Radar and Corporal Clinger (in a subliminal way) is not very clever, if your the Clash....
nick

-- Edited by TheTopHat at 23:00, 2007-06-07

__________________

there you go, big hand for the boomtown rats, music will never be the same again, i think........



House on Fire

Status: Offline
Posts: 125
Date:
Permalink  
 

Sorry, but I have to say that apart from the garish "Tonic For The Troops" cover, I liked most of the piccy art - although the cover for "Drag Me Down" should have been used as the cover for "In The Long Grass" instead.

And the man responsible for the cover for "Never In A Million Years" that played no small part in its flop should have been shot.

"V Deep" and "Fine Art Of Surfacing" were my two favourites.

Hmmm, perhaps we could have a competition for "alternative covers"...

The original Boomtown rats logo with the rats head peeping out of the guitar hole came from the original cover of James Herbert's The Rats, The Stranglers logo was stolen from Wrangler jeans (even if they did "make it bigger, Rickenbacker!" wink), the Sex Pistols ransom note one came c/o Jamie Reid's "Sniffin' Glue" fanzine, whilst the Clash's was in line with their Toytown Revolutionary pretensions

-- Edited by Mark Boyle at 21:25, 2007-06-08

__________________
If you can smile in the midst of pain And laugh at the cares of mankind You're out of the mire You're out of the rain And you're probably out of your mind


Dave

Status: Offline
Posts: 408
Date:
Permalink  
 

Mark Boyle wrote:

Sorry, but I have to say that apart from the garish "Tonic For The Troops" cover, I liked most of the piccy art - although the cover for "Drag Me Down" should have been used as the cover for "In The Long Grass" instead.

And the man responsible for the cover for "Never In A Million Years" that played no small part in its flop should have been shot.

"V Deep" and "Fine Art Of Surfacing" were my two favourites.

Hmmm, perhaps we could have a competition for "alternative covers"...

The original Boomtown rats logo with the rats head peeping out of the guitar hole came from the original cover of James Herbert's The Rats, The Stranglers logo was stolen from Wrangler jeans (even if they did "make it bigger, Rickenbacker!" wink), the Sex Pistols ransom note one came c/o Jamie Reid's "Sniffin' Glue" fanzine, whilst the Clash's was in line with their Toytown Revolutionary pretensions

-- Edited by Mark Boyle at 21:25, 2007-06-08




For the debut album? (ideally Rats would be dripping a little red!)

rats.GIF



apeing


41XQF3DDRFL._AA240_.jpg

or

31MZPCQVE4L._AA240_.jpg



 



__________________
 What is this guy talking about? 


The BoomTown Kid

Status: Offline
Posts: 154
Date:
Permalink  
 

So heres Tori Amos's Artwork on her cover of mondays, looks like shes dressed up as 'The Lone deRanger', which is presumably her twist on Brenda Spencer. 

http://www.thedent.com/elleslg.html

For the Boomtown Rats' "I Don't Like Mondays," for example, Amos re-created herself as a Charlie's Angels-esque Texas ranger, replete with big hair, frosted lipstick, and an ironic BABE pendant

You'll find the photo of Tori Amos here

http://www.thedent.com/strangelittlegirls.html


Heres another story... 
Rookie graphics artists story of designing Rats Artwork..??

http://www.accessmylibrary.com/comsite5/bin/pdinventory.pl?pdlanding=1&referid=2930&purchase_type=ITM&item_id=0286-13451540

nick   
 

-- Edited by TheTopHat at 10:43, 2007-06-12

__________________

there you go, big hand for the boomtown rats, music will never be the same again, i think........



Dave

Status: Offline
Posts: 408
Date:
Permalink  
 

TheTopHat wrote:
They definitely got it right on the first two albums.

Tonic for the Troops was very good, the front and back cover, expecially the dripping paint, and the black and white pictures inside, though I never really liked the scrapbook effect with the lyrics on the other side.  Never really liked the Clockwork/Modern covers, but Rat Trap was fine.

As for the first album, I think it lacked impact.  I prefer the Looking After No. 1 cover, but that said it isn't too bad in comparison with Surfacing.

V Deep has the best artwork by far, shame the album didn't match up to it.

I agree with the comment on the Million Years cover.  If there are to be holes on a sleeve then they should be over the label not the recorded surface. Though personally I think it was such a bad single, the cover made precious little difference.





__________________
 What is this guy talking about? 


Lookin' After Number 1

Status: Offline
Posts: 3
Date:
Permalink  
 

I think it may have been intentionally bad...they were a *punk* band, and according to the standards of the day....just an opinion.  And I agree V Deep had the best album art of all.  Does anyone have an mp3 of The Little Death?
I have been looking for that for nearly 5 years.  confused

-- Edited by Tsarina at 19:01, 2007-06-14

__________________
Where in the hell am I? And what am I doing in this handbasket?!?


The BoomTown Kid

Status: Offline
Posts: 154
Date:
Permalink  
 

'The little death' can be downloaded from itunes....
also Mary Coughlan, an Irish singer/songwriter, did a cover of it, its on an album called 'Uncertain Pleasures'
http://www.marycoughlanmusic.com/shop.php?id=48



As regards artwork and V Deep......
"(Ben) Kelley's other work has a simimilar sculptural feel for materials - his best effort being The Boomtown Rats' V Deep (1982) which is a definitive statement in micro detail fine design."
 whole article here....www.philipbrophy.com/projects/rstff/PostPunkGraphics_M.html


My favourite teeshirt is the closeup of Bobs face with the sunflowers in his eyes..although this isn't BTR material. I get a lotta laughs wearing it.
Also the pic which comes to mind is the heads on the broom handle with their tongues hanging out 'Tonic tour' (turkey stuff).


-- Edited by TheTopHat at 21:57, 2007-06-14

-- Edited by TheTopHat at 22:51, 2007-06-14

-- Edited by TheTopHat at 23:03, 2007-06-14

__________________

there you go, big hand for the boomtown rats, music will never be the same again, i think........



Dave

Status: Offline
Posts: 408
Date:
Permalink  
 

Tsarina wrote:

I think it may have been intentionally bad...they were a *punk* band, and according to the standards of the day....just an opinion.  And I agree V Deep had the best album art of all.  Does anyone have an mp3 of The Little Death?
I have been looking for that for nearly 5 years.  confused

-- Edited by Tsarina at 19:01, 2007-06-14



The standards of the day were higher than the Boomtown Rats.  Blondie,  The Stranglers  , The Pistols, The Jam , Sham 69, Elvis Costello and The Clash all had an image and a style which by and large they stuck by and made some iconic images of that era.  The only band I remember with worse covers were The Undertones

__________________
 What is this guy talking about? 


The BoomTown Kid

Status: Offline
Posts: 154
Date:
Permalink  
 

whether right or wrong, there were several members of the Rats who were 'savee' to graphics. Let us cast ourselves back to 1978. So yeah, some bands robbed the sex pistols artwork, ie. sham 69, boring album cover. However there was some great stuff put out by bands as well, at the time....agreed!

Arrgee wrote,
Blondie,  The Stranglers  , The Pistols, The Jam , Sham 69, Elvis Costello and The Clash all had an image and a style
So we're in 1978..... who are the biggest selling band? yep. Who can play live better than all their contempories? yep.
So what can the rest do to score points? sultry album covers?
It makes sense from their producers point of view.
I would assume the lack of 'interest' in graphical output, by the Rats was noted (But this point is debatable). In hindsight who knows!
There was a lot more interest in iconology by these other bands...
But the lyrics, the riffs..the rapport with Rats fans wich is probably what its all about, was second to none. It wasn't a punk thing. There was a definite interest in the fans.
Not that some of the other bands wern't good musically, ie. stranglers, Elvis Costello. But 'The Sex Pistols' GREAT! but eh who made the decision on Sid, (can't play but you look good) take a hike, fashion accessory! boring
Blondie, The band were great, but eh, what the..... is she singing about? Sunday girl n' telephones...hello! The Jam were always hooked into the MOD thing anyway, so thats seperate.
Its a bigger picture, are you really interested in their image.....
Kids maybe at the time .... But 30 years later....
Yeah, The Boomtown Rats will never be remembered for their 'ICONIC' graphics but you can't keep a good tune down!

__________________

there you go, big hand for the boomtown rats, music will never be the same again, i think........



Back To Boomtown

Status: Offline
Posts: 7207
Date:
Permalink  
 

TheTopHat wrote:
So we're in 1978..... who are the biggest selling band? yep.

Boney M or Abba smile  In terms of album sales, I suspect Blondie, the Sex Pistols and the Stranglers all fared better in 1978.


http://www.backdate.co.uk/1978_charts.htm
www.everyhit.com


TheTopHat wrote:


Yeah, The Boomtown Rats will never be remembered for their 'ICONIC' graphics but you can't keep a good tune down!


My point wasn't about the music, but why the artwork was so poor.  Was it because they got crap designers, didn't care, or because no one dared take the paints and crayons off Geldof?



-- Edited by ArrGee at 15:38, 2007-06-17

__________________

 What is this bloke talking about? 


The BoomTown Kid

Status: Offline
Posts: 154
Date:
Permalink  
 

The best selling band comment was about 'New Wave' specifically.... sorry I didn't make that clear. And I think your right about Blondie, http://www.backdate.co.uk/1978_acts.htm

Although some say Elvis Costello.

My memory was based on an NME poll which evaluated total album/single sales - chart position, guess I was wrong, but it was quite close.


The artwork.. as i've said already, its an overall image thing. Whether its good or bad is subjective, I think other bands were very image orientated, which can date easily, ...or can last as 'iconic'.

I couldn't speak for the Rats as to what their thinking was, my observation would be that they were interested in their artwork but were also aware of the 'package' that other bands were wrapping themselves in. ie. Blondie's (cool as ice, 'chic')... and The Clash's (militant) image.

I could only speculate. The Rats had (as a consistantly running image) a happy go lucky style. Does this translate through the artwork, not for me it doesn't.

I think a clue to this non engaged attitude is Bob wearing badges with his name spelt wrong.



__________________

there you go, big hand for the boomtown rats, music will never be the same again, i think........



Back To Boomtown

Status: Offline
Posts: 7207
Date:
Permalink  
 

TheTopHat wrote:

The best selling band comment was about 'New Wave' specifically.... sorry I didn't make that clear.


That's OK, I did get it, hence the smile.

If record sales had been measured from October 1978 - November 1979, then it is likely that The Boomtown Rats would have outsold everyone in that period with two number ones and two top ten albums. 

What I find interesting i sthat the biggest selling groups weren't as many would have you believe The Clash & The Jam, but Blondie, The Stranglers and The Boomtown Rats.  Neither The Jam nor the Clash sold much until the dawn of the eighties; for The Clash it may well have been the nineties when they were discovered through the Levi ads.

I think one of the things the Rats didn't do well was image.  They sounded great, they were photogenic, yet when it came down to the artwork it never gelled, apart from Tonic for the Troops which did work, and is probably the most enduring image.




__________________

 What is this bloke talking about? 


The BoomTown Kid

Status: Offline
Posts: 154
Date:
Permalink  
 

I would be interested in finding out who designed all this artwork, what was the brief they were given, and how they came up with the final artwork.
Was there an art director working for the rats?
I wonder who these peoples' clients are these days?
The designer of 'tonic' could definitely pitch for my next run of letter heads/business cards!

I'll give him a brief.....

nick.

__________________

there you go, big hand for the boomtown rats, music will never be the same again, i think........



CRAZY

Status: Offline
Posts: 174
Date:
Permalink  
 

Bob's last CD had his girlfriend on it.  Do you think she got paid?  Any bets? smile

You can't take it with you, Bob! biggrin

O'Shora

__________________

Give Peace A Chance...



Loudmouth

Status: Offline
Posts: 2193
Date:
Permalink  
 

I used to think that too, Oshora, until Ian put a post here, saying it was an american girl on the cover. She still keeps in contact now and then, I  think.

__________________
Cheers, keep singing, Scottie
"Music is the wine that fills the cup of silence".
http://twitter.com/#!/BobGeldofFans


Lookin' After Number 1

Status: Offline
Posts: 1
Date:
Permalink  
 

What edition of Tonic is this? http://www.flickr.com/photos/samandjo/5514843760/

The stars are not on any other edition.



__________________


Loudmouth

Status: Offline
Posts: 2821
Date:
Permalink  
 

The reply underneath the photo, from frost-ie says his/her copy also has two stars on the cover. Tried various Google searches but didn't come up with anything. It would be interesting to hear from Frost-ie why he/ she purchased the album.

Maybe they were some sort of promo, or radio station or test copies. Maybe the stars go with the military aspect  ie with troops and its some sort of in joke. It may be just a Photoshop conspiracy.

Does anyone else have any onomalies on Rats cover art? Generally as regards covers I think the first album is brilliant- one of my favourite album covers of all time. The greatest hits does what is says on the tin- with a pretty decent photo.



-- Edited by noelindublin on Sunday 24th of July 2011 01:07:50 PM



-- Edited by noelindublin on Sunday 24th of July 2011 01:10:16 PM

__________________


Back To Boomtown

Status: Offline
Posts: 7207
Date:
Permalink  
 

noelindublin wrote:

Maybe they were some sort of promo, or radio station or test copies. 


It's the most likely explanation.  Another is that when record companies used to get returns they'd stamp the cover or punch a hole in it, sometimes through the label, to devalue the record before passing it onto wholesalers who would sell it via newsagents.  Jukebox 7" were often sold this way as well.

Not sure there is anything special about the stars.



__________________

 What is this bloke talking about? 


Loudmouth

Status: Offline
Posts: 2821
Date:
Permalink  
 

The artwork in general may have been a bit of a mish mash but it never bothered me, going on the old maxim never judge a book by its cover. The only truly bad cover for me was the Never In  A Million Years Cover- why the holes, and why no name or band identity. I love it as a song but the artwork was more than careless- but I don't think that had anything to do with the song not charting- the band was just doing something a bit less predictable.

I think the V Deep cover is possibly the worst album cover- but again its the contents that are most important. In their favour the Rats didn't, unwittingly or not, have a studied, cool look in their graphics. It all came on a  take it or leave it basic. Of course this was the era before graphic design became a cool career choice and there was a lot of just plain art naivete around. Punk covers came with a diy feel, steering away from the professional hand. What input the band themselves had in choosing covers is open to debate- most likely they had little or none. I doubt if Bob Geldof was fretting over what pic should go on what cover, equally in the early days surely the covers envisaged would concern the band to some extend.

Sometimes trying too hard  be cool does not work, in art as in life.



__________________


Back To Boomtown

Status: Offline
Posts: 7207
Date:
Permalink  
 

Jules wrote:

I'm sure we all know that the answer is that they (well Bob) was too tight to pay for anything more professional.


 Hence the stock image!



__________________

 What is this bloke talking about? 


Loudmouth

Status: Offline
Posts: 2631
Date:
Permalink  
 

Not seen this thread before. Interesting and will have a fuller look after work. 



__________________
Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard