POSTING GUIDELINES
This forum is intended to provide an atmosphere of open communication, where each member can share his or her own insights and opinions. To help achieve this goal, we ask that you:
Do not post libelous or illegal material.
Do not post harassing or discriminatory comments based on race, ethnic origin, gender, or sexual orientation.
Do not solicit or advertise.
If you have questions or comments about this forum (such as technical difficulties or performance issues), please contact your forum administrator for the appropriate channel for your inquiry.
Moderation
Any post that violates the above conditions, or departs from the intended purpose of this forum may be removed without notice by the administration.
We reserve the right to edit any post for reasons including, but not limited to: language, length, or content not appropriate to the topic of this forum.
Older threads or messages may be removed from time to time, to main to maintain categories or threads of manageable length.
Any member who breaches these Guidelines through hostile, abusive or other inappropriate behavior may find their account privileges revoked.
Privacy
Remember that this is a public forum, and you have no guarantee or expectation of privacy. Your post could be read by anyone.
Posts can be traced. We record information about every user of this forum, and will honor any court orders or requests by recognized law authorities for information about individuals posting libelous material.
All communications on this board are deemed to by public and not private communications. We reserve the right to remove without notice any message posted for any reason, but we have no obligation to remove content you find objectionable.
Regarding your email address and other personal information
Although we require your email address for verification purposes, we recommend that you do not post it or any other personal information such, as phone numbers or your home address. Your posts can be searched by bots or third parties that have no affiliation with the administrator of this forum.
Disclaimer
The views expressed by members of this forum are their own and do not reflect the position of the administrator or other members. Each member is responsible for the content of his/her own posts.
Please report any activity that you notice which is libelous, inflammatory, or in violation of common decency to the management immediately.
Since a 'favorite Rats song' question has been posted, it made me wonder - what solo songs of Geldof's do you all like? I haven't heard too much, but from what I've listened to so far, my favs are: Crazy Love or Something Thinking Voyager 2 Type Things The Chains of Pain One For Me My Birthday Suit Scream in Vain
My fav's are, 10:15, My birthday suit, Scream in vain, One for me, Pale white girls, Crazy and The great song of indifference. ( But really there is'nt a song i don't like as of yet.)
And this is where I get flamed, I don't have any others!
It's not that I find the solo stuff that bad, it's just that I tend to never come back to it.
I was not impressed with Deep in the Heart of Nowhere (though as my first CD it got played a lot), I did like Vegetarians but never listen to it anymore, Happy Club probably got a once over, and I'm not sure if I have listened to SA&D all the way through yet.
lol that's ok ArrGee...I kinda get where you're coming from, I think. Geldof has his own styles of music, pretty different from the Rats stuff. From the Loudmouth CD (my first Rats/Geldof-related audio purchase), I definitely liked the Rats songs better than Rats-less Geldof. I did like a couple (mentioned already), but the rest were just average. The Vegetarians of Love I think would be great dinner or background music, in my opinion, and only a couple stood out for me.
I have not listened to 'The Happy Club' yet, I wish to soon, though. Sex Age and Death is my favorite of his so far, because it peels away from the accordian-fiddle-upbeat-jiggy style that I don't particularly care for, and there is an interesting variety of stuff here.
Though I would say overall I like the Rats stuff better, I always enjoy hearing Geldof's voice nonetheless, and obviously his solo work is one way to hear it!
If you can smile in the midst of pain
And laugh at the cares of mankind
You're out of the mire
You're out of the rain
And you're probably out of your mind
quote: Originally posted by: Katharina "This is the world calling, Beat of the night; Love or something, Crucified me; My hippy angel, Like down on me; Pale white girls, Scream in vain. And a day that starts with The Happy Club is likely to be a good day! If I had to name the song I like least it would be Song of the emergent nationalist. "
I knew I'd find it! My favorite is Emergent Nationalist, and if only I could have remembered the damned title, I'd have requested it when BG was touring with Jamie. Wonder if THEY'D have remembered it, though.
Happy Club (the track) was on repeat in the player the day I graduated from law school.
S/A/D is in a category all by itself.
I'll restrain myself from listing more, because there's lots more.
nanana, nanana, nanana (I just put Happy Club on again!)
I have read mixed reviews of 'Deep in the Heart of Nowhere.' For those of you who have it or have heard it, what's your opinion of the album? Weak? So-so? Praise-worthy? etc
Actually, I've been thinking about this a lot since a conversation I had Sunday night, and after watching the Brits clip. This relates to my problems with the Rats as well, or as much of the Rats as I've heard (which isn't much).
I think "Deep in the Heart" is utter crap. I just hate it.
But - I'm beginning to think that my problem isn't with the lyrics, and for the most part, might not be with Rats lyrics either. There's a certain sound that was oh-so-popular in the 80s, and that sound has always been like nails on a chalkboard to me. Deep in the Heart is a perfect example (Dave Stewart was never my cup of tea), and there are a lot of Rats tunes that seem to have more synth than I can stand, sharing a similar feel. (There are some Rats tunes that are a lot harder & edgier, and I seem to like those.) It might be that if they were all more leanly produced, I'd like them all. I don't think it's the lyrics, or the essential song structure that I have a problem with - I'm beginning to think it's the arrangements; and I think they were part of a place and time that I could never quite get into. I'm more of an r&b sort of girl - give me the funk.
So, if you liked 80s rock, you'll probably like Deep in the Heart. I think I spent a lot of time in the 80s discovering country and really getting into gospel (Mahalia Jackson, Shirley Caesar - that sort of thing), because I hated the big-hair/"Britpop" sound that was popular at the time.
Sorry to be so long-winded, but it just happens to be what I've been thinking about lately.
great reply, fran I don't mind your long windedness at all!
I do like a lot of 80s stuff, and I think I do like that overall 'sound structure' you're talking about...so maybe I should check it out. get a cheap copy from eBay, that's where I'm getting all my solo Geldof stuff (not including SA&D...that was available on amazon!).
But, I didn't like "This is the World Calling" (no offense to those who like it!), I was not impressed with those women background vocals. I don't dig that lol. That song was, IMO, kinda cheesy and almost 'We Are the World' sounding. Not awful but not great. Would you say, fran, that the rest of the album sound falls into that song's same musical category (ie, it's a good representation of the whole album)?
Thanks, I guess - but I'm not a pro at all. It's weird, I don't think I have the vocabulary to even begin to describe what I'm trying to say when I try and talk about music. For all I know, I may have completely botched what I was trying to communicate.
I wake up every morning hoping to be Aretha Franklin, but it hasn't actually happened yet. I haven't played an instrument since I was about 9 years old (smacked the violin against the wall by accident and snapped off the neck - my family wouldn't believe it was unintentional, because I'd been bitching about my 9am Saturday morning lessons); and I do most of my singing in the shower.
There was only one time I walked into a studio, to record a single measly line in a song (a la Band Aid)...I was standing there, staring down the microphone and the stocking thing - I thought I was going to throw up on the spot. Thank God, I managed to do it on key in one take.
I'd like to learn how to play piano before I die.
I almost married a musician, but I don't think that has much to do with it. I guess I just like to listen.
I'm a visual artist. I know how to talk about RGB and CMYK, shadow, highlight and contrast... stuff like that. I do have a pretty big record collection, though.
quote: Originally posted by: MMbullybuddyGP Would you say, fran, that the rest of the album sound falls into that song's same musical category (ie, it's a good representation of the whole album)?
Oh God, you mean you want me to LISTEN to the whole thing? I don't think I can take it. You'll have to give me a week or so to work up to that! I really don't like that record. OK, OK, for the sake of research...
no you don't have to. I thought maybe if you had a first-impression thought of 'this is the world calling' being like the rest of the album, you could share, but if that means you gotta subject your ears to such horrors...perhaps not worth it
singing in the shower is always good. that and bursting out in song alone in your car, with some great tunes...
quote: Originally posted by: MJ "I picked Pale White Girls, but only because my real favorite, A Gospel Song, wasn't listed and "None of the above" sucked. I'd also put The Great Song of Indifference in my top favorites."
Unfortunately there are only 20 options allowed, but I will add A Gospel Song to the list so you can vote for it (though as you have already voted it may prevent you, but others will get the chance )
Hmmmm....my favorite is Emergent Nationalist. Probably no need to add it to the list, because I think everyone else hates it. I know it's Katharina's most hated of all.
(Still wonder what Jamie did to merit co-writing credit.)
Have never heard Sunny Afternoon. What the hell is that from?
quote: Originally posted by: franna "Have never heard Sunny Afternoon. What the hell is that from?"
It's a cover of The Kinks' song. It's not bad. Here.
ETA: From what I could find, it was written by Ray Davies in 1966. I don't know if he recorded it though. I knew only of The Kinks' version before Bob sang it.
One For Me or Mudslide.No no no wait When I Was Young.No no no wait again A Gospel Song.No no no wait again August Was A Heavy Month.No no no wait yet again Soft Soil or This Is The World Calling.No no no wait yet again 10.15 or , or . Damn: it, just to many good songs to choose from.
I dont listen to anything else apart from bob geldof, and the Boomtown rats!
okay, so i love the boomtown rats and i love bob geldofs music, but come on, dont limit urself to just them, ud be missing out on a great era of music....love the 70s and 80s
Those of you who say you have not listened much to some albums, i can only say to you that you are missing something.
Here are some of my suggestions for peopl who may not know much about Bob's solo music
I have been a fan of Geldof since very early times and i actually like the solo stuff as the Rats.
Rose at night is brilliant...why is it not mentioned? the vegetarians of love album has some great tracks on it and has a brilliant feel to the whole album, i can play it at any time and still love it....No small wonder, gospel song, voyager 2 type things,crucified me, walking back to happiness are great tracks as well as the more popular great song of indifference and chains of pain....indigenous and addictive sound on the whole album. If you haven't heard it much or ever, get a copy and listen to it a few times, when it grows on you, you will be glad you did.
Beat of the night...Excellent, as are may songs from deep in the heart of nowhere
Emergant nationalist, room 19, attitude chicken, hippy angel.....go and listen to that album again! (happy club) but for me i loved whole to fill, energy, feeling and typical Geldof..Brilliant!
Sex age and death is probably the most popular album, some brilliant songs, i love mudslide, inside your head, 10.15, pale white girls......all of it...i like most of what Geldof does:) it grows on you if you listen to it with an open mind, give it a try and if you get the chance to see Bob in concert, i know you will love it. Gone are the days of massive crowds in big halls like the Rats had, but Bob on his own in smaller halls is one of the best experiences you will ever have!
__________________
Been a Rats and Geldof fan since 16 years old, now 40 at the time of writing:)
Tough Question! They're all great - but... if I had to, erm, narrow it down?
Roughly -
August Was a Heavy Month Talk Me Up Great Song of Indifference Thinking Voyager II Type Thoughts Soft Soil Like Down on Me (especially after seeing it live!) My Hippy Angel (The long version from the single!) Mudslide Cool Blue and Easy
Though, if I gave it some thought, I'd come up with a dozen others. Love em all.