POSTING GUIDELINES
This forum is intended to provide an atmosphere of open communication, where each member can share his or her own insights and opinions. To help achieve this goal, we ask that you:
Do not post libelous or illegal material.
Do not post harassing or discriminatory comments based on race, ethnic origin, gender, or sexual orientation.
Do not solicit or advertise.
If you have questions or comments about this forum (such as technical difficulties or performance issues), please contact your forum administrator for the appropriate channel for your inquiry.
Moderation
Any post that violates the above conditions, or departs from the intended purpose of this forum may be removed without notice by the administration.
We reserve the right to edit any post for reasons including, but not limited to: language, length, or content not appropriate to the topic of this forum.
Older threads or messages may be removed from time to time, to main to maintain categories or threads of manageable length.
Any member who breaches these Guidelines through hostile, abusive or other inappropriate behavior may find their account privileges revoked.
Privacy
Remember that this is a public forum, and you have no guarantee or expectation of privacy. Your post could be read by anyone.
Posts can be traced. We record information about every user of this forum, and will honor any court orders or requests by recognized law authorities for information about individuals posting libelous material.
All communications on this board are deemed to by public and not private communications. We reserve the right to remove without notice any message posted for any reason, but we have no obligation to remove content you find objectionable.
Regarding your email address and other personal information
Although we require your email address for verification purposes, we recommend that you do not post it or any other personal information such, as phone numbers or your home address. Your posts can be searched by bots or third parties that have no affiliation with the administrator of this forum.
Disclaimer
The views expressed by members of this forum are their own and do not reflect the position of the administrator or other members. Each member is responsible for the content of his/her own posts.
Please report any activity that you notice which is libelous, inflammatory, or in violation of common decency to the management immediately.
tis that time again for another review. this album needs some support since it’s so shunned by many Geldof fans which is understandable to some extent… It’s my favorite solo BG album No country/Irish sounds here (with the exception of one track which I’ll get to soon), some very, very pretty tunes. Until now it’s been SA&D, but this one’s now at the top because not only does it have some striking tracks like SA&D…it doesn’t have all the personal and emotional baggage that SA&D holds. I was most impressed with Geldof’s vocal range and control here. Until hearing this album, I felt that he wasn’t the best at controlling his pitch and what he was trying to do with his voice, but this CD proved me wrong. In my opinion, much of his most interesting solo vocal work is right here, he went all over the place! Beautiful vocal work, as good as BG’s voice can get Some things I wasn’t too impressed with here. Most of the music was so, so weak (overuse of synthesizers n such … yikes). and I could not stand the stupid female backing vocals infesting mostly every song, go away! even if it was the cool Annie Lennox (& others), she and the rest of ‘em always made the songs even more cheesy than the music made them already. BG obviously dominated the production and work of this album (more so than any BTR stuff and the other solo albums, I felt), which has its positives and negatives. so, track by track… This is the world calling This one really stands out because I still think of it as a Loudmouth track (where I heard it first), not a DITHON one – it’s hard to compare this to the rest of the album. This was never a favorite of mine. It’s so corny lyrically, any song that focuses on the ‘world’ is usually so. The tune is average and I hate the backing vocals. It’s down there, probably my third-to-least favorite track. In the pouring rain This one’s also average. Nothing special, nothing horrible. It gets better in the end, the whole ‘I’m gonna walk on by’ verse. I like the higher intensity of emotion BG uses there, and the beat stands out more. The lyrics are ok, kinda amateuristic (not even a word but who cares). August was a heavy month A nice track - very soothing and hypnotic, with a decent tune. It’s nice to hear Bob sing in a high pitch range (in the verses, I mean), he pulled it off fantastically, never missing a note. I loved every time he did the ‘alright alright’ bit, cool. The lyrics are mysterious and interesting, though every time he mentions ‘Baby Blue’ I can’t help but think of Pink Floyd/The Wall’s “The Thin Ice” song, where ‘baby blue’s also sung of. That’s not necessarily a bad thing, just kinda random. A relief to hear no wretched backing vocals. Love like a rocket This one seems to appeal to some folks, I don’t get it. I think it’s boring, kind of annoying, and out of tune! The metallic sound striking throughout the track is much flatter than the synthesizer’s work, it’s horrible. The refrain is repetitive as are the verses, it’s just like…all right, we get the point, next song. The wee bit of excitement occurs during the lines right before the refrain when Bob inflects his voice randomly (‘then sighs and mutters something sounding close to despair,’ etc.). And I really can’t get over how phallic the whole rocket thing is, especially associated with love. Gary Oldman once said that a movie was good to him if it made it feel a ‘rocket’s gone up his ass’ when he leaves the theatre. This comes to mind too. I Cry Too This one made my heart skip a few times! I love, love, love this track, wow. A lovely ballad song thing with an outstanding tune. After ‘My Birthday Suit,’ this is my favorite BG solo song. Bob being off tune a little here and there doesn’t even faze me because it’s such a beautiful song. The best, best, best lines ever tune-wise are when he croons “It got so hard…it gets so hard…” aaah nice. So much ‘umph’/power here, and in the refrain. Also adore the key change near the song’s end. heartrending but fine lyrics. The backing vocals (‘baby, baby’) actually work here. When I was young Hmm…this one sounds a little like the Beauty and the Beast title song, it has a part of the same tune (‘when I wa-as young’ vs. ‘ever just the same’). It’s a forcibly upbeat/cheery song, something isn’t working here. I really liked the beginning and end ‘verses’ as they were very unique. The ‘live fast, be a supernova’ line was neat in the first verse, as was a lot of the beat/time changes…I was thinking, wtf’s going on with this song?...but that inconsistency worked. then the end (‘baby baby baby, when there’s nothin left to do…’) blended in nicely and improved the refrain’s tune. Poetic yet slightly cheesy lyrics. Annoying backing vocals. An odd song that sometimes worked, sometimes not. This heartless heart Strange ‘music,’ but the rhythm did sound kinda like a beating heart. The track is almost Bowie-esque. Sorta pretty, sorta not. Again, the backing vocals need to die, and the lyrics leave something more to be desired. Him saying ‘crap’ at the end kinda undermined the seriousness the song seemed to be trying to pull off. The best part of the song is the line “I’m tired of hearing remedies for things that really never needed cures!...” Lyrically it’s neat, but I especially liked Bob’s vocals, a nice punch that line packed into this otherwise average track. The beat of the night Another Loudmouth track in my mind, and this is also one I don’t care for too much. Sounds like an album-filler to me. Confusing lyrics, dumb-as-always backing vocals, boring tune and Bob vocal work. My second-to-least favorite track here. Truly true blue yea for two lame tracks in a row! This is my least favorite song. Pushing country-sounding, Bob’s guitar playing is not that great here. I don’t like his singing either, it’s drawn out and kind of in a breathless ramble. Overall the song is not tight or professional sounding. The lyrics are not bad but the rest of the track’s elements are weak. next! Pulled apart by horses Startling beginning, very upbeat, keeps my attention the entire time. A strong track void of the horrid backing vocals (since ‘they’re’ Bob’s own voice!). Much emotional effort of Bob’s was put into singing this song it seems, and it works nicely. The music has a Western sound to it, appropriate for the horse motif in this track. The frenzied lyrics fit with the overall style of the song. Words from heaven The opening music & refrain sounds like some cheap anime theme song which turned me quite off, until Bob came in and saved the song from its extreme cheesiness! I loved his vocal work here, especially those lovely inflections woven throughout the verses (‘don’t be confu-hoooo-wo-wo-wused,’ ‘I’m happy for you-hoooo-wo wo wou,’ etc.), excellent. Also the tune to the lines “where you lived without a trace,” “you sat till you never cracked,” etc. were quite pleasing to my ears. Average lyrics. The refrain sucks, unfortunately, as does the synthesized music, but the beautiful verses compensate the bad of this song, making it a little-better-than-average track. Good boys in the wrong awesome, awesome rhythm/beat here, very ‘jammable.’ Suave vocal work by the gob throughout. The ‘start me up and help me get away’ line’s tune comes from nowhere, but it’s interesting and kinda works. Once again the backing vocals fail to impress. Otherwise, a good, strong track. Night turns to day Another Bowie-sounding track, more so musically than vocally. Bob sounds most like a Bowie imitation during the “and finds me…and leaves me…” parts of the refrain. Nice vocal work from Bob, a pretty/pushing-corny-sounding tune. The bridge verse (“I never think that there’s any of this will touch you…”) is pretty. Lyrically, there’s an attractive mix of disturbing and hope. The line “His gums a mute and bleeding mess of teeth” is a disgusting contrast to the ‘happy’ tune, but I think that’s cool. Overall, a well-put-together track. Deep in the heart of nowhere A wistful, kinda depressing, powerful little track. Lyrically, there’s a craving for someone, a sorrowful hoping that this person will return. It sounds like a very appropriate song for Paula after she left him, but obviously this song was done before that whole fiasco, so it would be interesting to know the story behind it. The Bob-guitar duet actually sounds good & together here (usually I don’t like this simple combination). The song’s ending is strange and kind of makes you think, since it sounds very open-ended or something. An interesting way to end an album. I liked it a lot. whew
Good review.It is funny how people relate to the differant songs.I love THIS IS THE WORLD CALLING and WHEN I WAS YOUNG but I am not to keen on I CRY TOO or LOVE LIKE A ROCKET.AUGUST WAS A HEAVY MONTH for me is pure brilliance.Eric Clapton on guitar is just f5cking superb.The "12" inch version of THIS IS THE WORLD CALLING is also a big favourite of mine.
Wow Mmbullybuddy, a great review! Very precise, well written and some very interesting observations... I'm glad I'm not the only one who sees the good sides of this album! Obvioulsy, I disagree in some aspects (for example, I've never thought of "Beat of the night" as an album filler, probably because I've seen it performed live a "few" times and it was always a highlight during shows...). But I agree in others. And: Very interesting that "phallic" association of yours, with Gary Oldman...
aw...thanks derek and katharina for the compliments I really enjoy writing them hehe. kat, good point about BOTN...I'm sure if I see some of these songs live, (someday, hopefully!) I'd feel differently...just goin' solely on the CD tracks themselves...
now for a shameful plug (don't like sounding pompous!) - I've posted reviews of the BTR debut album (under 'Utterly Subjective...'), of V Deep (under 'reviews'), and of The Happy Club (under 'noone got anything to say')...in case you're bored and have nothing better to read (though most of you have read 'em already, I'm sure!). More to come b/c, like I said, it's fun for me to do this