Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Boomtown Rats -> The Boomtown Rats -> Bob Geldof -> Songs dropped from original October album release?
Post Info TOPIC: Songs dropped from original October album release?
noelindublin


Loudmouth

Status: Offline
Posts: 2821
Date:
Songs dropped from original October album release?
Permalink  
 

Just noticed that How To Sell has only ten tracks. I may be mistaken but the original line up possibly had twelve songs for the October release or maybe it was my imagination.

If so we'll be getting a trimmed down version. Geldof once claimed that if you can't say it all in ten songs then you shouldn't pad it out with say twelve or fifteen songs.

The problem with this is that sometimes the "dropped" songs are better that those selected by either the record label or the artist (Geldof ) himself. It is a matter of personal preference which songs appeal to the individual so I'd kinda have preferred a longer version.

Anyway if there are unreleased songs at least they have been recorded and will eventually see the light of day. Don't think they do cd singles anymore which usually gave the b sides. Geldof and the Rats always had good b sides  so hopefully other tracks will emerge later not on the February release.

I suppose the album has to have some sort of uniformity of feel or loose theme rather that a mishmash of songs that may not fit together in a coherent way.


-- Edited by noelindublin on Monday 20th of December 2010 02:17:43 PM

-- Edited by noelindublin on Monday 20th of December 2010 02:19:42 PM

__________________
Derek The Dane


V Deep

Status: Offline
Posts: 963
Date:
Permalink  
 

HMV still has 14 songs? listed.I hope they do not cut it down.

__________________
noelindublin


Loudmouth

Status: Offline
Posts: 2821
Date:
Permalink  
 

Hi Derek - Bobs official site only lists ten songs and also on Amazon it only contains ten songs. You can check these sites to see for yourself!

Jules Geldof Facebook site may be of help.

__________________
Scottie


Loudmouth

Status: Offline
Posts: 2193
Date:
Permalink  
 

One od the Aussie papers said there was also a "secret track" Whatever that is.

__________________
Cheers, keep singing, Scottie
"Music is the wine that fills the cup of silence".
http://twitter.com/#!/BobGeldofFans
noelindublin


Loudmouth

Status: Offline
Posts: 2821
Date:
Permalink  
 

Scottie wrote:

One od the Aussie papers said there was also a "secret track" Whatever that is.


A "secret track " is more commonly known as a buried track. You play the album through and think its all over, then if you've still left the cd in the stereo the extra unlisted track will come on after maybe one or two minutes.

So the thing to do is leave the cd running and you'll get to hear the extra song.

Its a bit gimmicky but I'm sure its done for some good reason.

Oh yeah its normally called a hidden track.

 



__________________
Derek The Dane


V Deep

Status: Offline
Posts: 963
Date:
Permalink  
 

HMV now only have 10 songs listed.no

__________________
noelindublin


Loudmouth

Status: Offline
Posts: 2821
Date:
Permalink  
 

Derek The Dane wrote:

HMV now only have 10 songs listed.no


I wonder did the record company have the fourteen track cd manufactured and ready to go in October before it was shelved. It probably went out to various magazines to review.

Its fairly common nowadays for an initial album to come out and then later a deluxe addition containing more songs. Goldfrapp did that with their great album Seventh Tree. It contained more songs and some live versions of the original.

Thing about that is that you end up buying the album twice. Maybe judicious downloading of selected tracks in the better option.

I'm sure we'll get to hear all of the Geldof tracks eventually. Or everyone mad enough will!

 



-- Edited by noelindublin on Wednesday 22nd of December 2010 01:40:06 PM

__________________
ArrGee


Back To Boomtown

Status: Offline
Posts: 7207
Date:
Permalink  
 

noelindublin wrote:
I wonder did the record company have the fourteen track cd manufactured and ready to go in October before it was shelved. It probably went out to various magazines to review.

Almost certainly there were downloads/streams of the 14 tracks (there is a site that journalists use for this but I can't remember its name) and most likely some CDs.   I suspect some CDs may come to light (a la SAD Too) with all 14 tracks.  So check eBay!

 



__________________

 What is this bloke talking about? 
noelindublin


Loudmouth

Status: Offline
Posts: 2821
Date:
Permalink  
 

ArrGee wrote:

noelindublin wrote:
I wonder did the record company have the fourteen track cd manufactured and ready to go in October before it was shelved. It probably went out to various magazines to review.

Almost certainly there were downloads/streams of the 14 tracks (there is a site that journalists use for this but I can't remember its name) and most likely some CDs.   I suspect some CDs may come to light (a la SAD Too) with all 14 tracks.  So check eBay!

 


Maybe they did a survey of all the reviews and dropped the songs the journos specifically mentioned as not too good.

Anyway part of being a functioning human being is to trust your own judgement so who needs music journalists to do that for them?

I expect there to be maybe three or four really good tracks, four or five ok/acceptable songs and a couple of turkeys. Its the same with almost all music I listen too.

Geldof solo will never have the same impact as the Boomtown Rats in their prime and I think he knows that too- but its a new chapter in a book I have to read. I want to know what happens next I've come this far.

 



__________________
bosmethaar


Lookin' After Number 1

Status: Offline
Posts: 3
Date:
Permalink  
 

I did find a 15 track promo with the 4 songs which did t made the final release and don't know why not , like these songs too



__________________
noelindublin


Loudmouth

Status: Offline
Posts: 2821
Date:
Permalink  
 

bosmethaar wrote:

I did find a 15 track promo with the 4 songs which did t made the final release and don't know why not , like these songs too

 Haven't seen this. Is it on Ebay?

Have you heard the four tracks not features on the original album? If so a short description of what they are like would be interesting ie the style- folk, rock , punk or whatever and if you think they are any good.

Geldof has stated a few times that he recorded about twenty extra songs which did not feature on the oringinal release. This means there are a good fifteen more songs lying around still.

Whether the world is clamouring for them to be heard is another matter!



__________________
Jules


The biggest Geldof fan in the world, bar none!

Status: Offline
Posts: 6293
Date:
Permalink  
 

I found it on eBay.  Keep looking if you want it.



__________________
Love Julesxxx
Bob's personal Hippy Angel - well in my dreams ;-)
http://www.facebook.com/home.php#/profile.php?id=709427348&ref=profile
http://www.facebook.com/BobGeldofFans
Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.
Boomtown Rats -> The Boomtown Rats -> Bob Geldof -> Songs dropped from original October album release?
Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse 		Powered by ActiveBoard